Understanding Canadian Citizenship by Descent: The Case of Clifford

If your grandparent was born in Canada and later became an American, you may be a Canadian citizen by descent. You may have been one since the day you were born.

Canada’s immigration department used a family like yours to train its own officers on these cases. In December 2025, according to internal IRCC training materials released through an access to information request, officers studied the case of “Clifford.” He’s a hypothetical American, born in 1998.

Under Canada’s new citizenship law, Clifford is Canadian. His citizenship counts from his date of birth.

Clifford’s family at a glance

IRCC’s example runs across three generations.

Generation Born Status before December 15, 2025 Status today
Grandparent Canada, 1938 Moved to the U.S. and lost Canadian citizenship on becoming American; restored in 2009 Canadian
Parent Outside Canada Canadian, as the first generation born abroad Canadian
Clifford United States, 1998 Not a citizen, because of the first-generation limit Canadian

What is the first-generation limit?

From 2009 until December 2025, Canadian citizenship could pass down to only one generation born outside Canada.

Clifford’s parent was the first generation born outside Canada, so the parent counted. Clifford was the second, so he didn’t. Bill C-3 removed the limit for everyone born before December 15, 2025.

How four laws shaped Clifford’s family

Four laws over 78 years shaped Clifford’s family. A fifth, in 2015, covered people who lost their status before 1947.

Year What changed What it meant for families like Clifford’s
1947 Canada’s first citizenship law took effect. It didn’t allow dual citizenship. Canadians who took another country’s citizenship lost their Canadian citizenship in most cases.
1977 A new Citizenship Act allowed dual citizenship from February 15, 1977. Canadians who became Americans from that date on kept their citizenship. Parliament didn’t reverse earlier losses.
2009 and 2015 Two laws restored most “Lost Canadians” and their children born abroad: 2009 for losses from 1947 on, and 2015 for those who lost their status before 1947. The 2009 law also limited citizenship